Yavesh Rana's commen

Friday, December 15, 2006 Answer To Yavesh rana's comment "She is no good writer--even a street urchin can write better--but lo she got the award for the sickening book--" THE GOD OF SMALL THINGS". AN utter nonsense by literary standards. She managed an award. HOW?--god alone knows." To this comment of Yavesh on the POTD I have this comment below Yavesh, How many awards have you got for literary works? How many books have you written? Furnish the details and who has published it, viz penguin etc. I want to see the real standard of the literary work. It should be not the one like Arundhati Roy. 6:12:34 PM Posted By Macho Man Comments (3) Personals Comments Roger Friday, December 15, 2006 6:36:55 PM Exactly! This fellow writes pseudo intellectual nonsense, considers everyone who doesnt agree with his views an ISI agent, has the typical mindset of the fanatic, not willing to reason or debate, but demands everyone else should have an open mind!! Talk about practicing what you plreach!! Judgemental and arrogant, a complete waste of space. jawab Friday, December 15, 2006 7:18:48 PM Tu fir aa gaya saala delete karke mera pehla comment.toh yeh saala roger bhi tum hi ho raksho ki machaso. mirchi kiyon lad rahi hai tum ko. bahut gussa hai yaveshh bhaiyya pe.usne tumko ISI agent bola.nahi ho kiya.aur kiya bola wo tum sabko.gaali bhi diya.samjha denge tum saala rona band karo. CHUPP K.Venugopal Friday, December 15, 2006 7:31:03 PM Yavesh Rana's comments and Macho Man's response reminded me of the saying, "I may not be able to lay eggs but I certainly know a good omelet from a bad one." Yavesh has critiqued Arundhati, but how many critiques write award winning novels? I, anyway, think Arundhati is a terrific writer and she is best as an essayist.